Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies

Leslie A. Rescorla, Sofia Ginzburg, Thomas M. Achenbach, Masha Y. Ivanova, Fredrik Almqvist, Ivan Begovac, Niels Bilenberg, Hector Bird, Myriam Chahed, Anca Dobrean, Manfred Döpfner, Nese Erol, Helga Hannesdottir, Yasuko Kanbayashi, Michael C. Lambert, Patrick W L Leung, Asghar Minaei, Torunn S. Novik, Kyung Ja Oh, Djaouida PetotJean Michel Petot, Rolando Pomalima, Vlasta Rudan, Michael Sawyer, Zeynep Simsek, Hans Christoph Steinhausen, José Valverde, Jan van der Ende, Sheila Weintraub, Christa Winkler Metzke, Tomasz Wolanczyk, Eugene Yuqing Zhang, Rita Zukauskiene, Frank C. Verhulst

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    108 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    We used population sample data from 25 societies to answer the following questions: (a) How consistently across societies do adolescents report more problems than their parents report about them? (b) Do levels of parent-adolescent agreement vary among societies for different kinds of problems? (c) How well do parents and adolescents in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-adolescent dyads within each society vary in agreement on item ratings? (e) How well do parent-adolescent dyads within each society agree on the adolescent's deviance status? We used five methods to test cross-informant agreement for ratings obtained from 27,861 adolescents ages 11 to 18 and their parents. Youth Self-Report (YSR) mean scores were significantly higher than Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) mean scores for all problem scales in almost all societies, but the magnitude of the YSR-CBCL discrepancy varied across societies. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied more across societies than across types of problems. Across societies, parents and adolescents tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad parent-adolescent item agreement varied widely in every society. In all societies, both parental noncorroboration of self-reported deviance and adolescent noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Results indicated many multicultural consistencies but also some important differences in parent-adolescent cross-informant agreement. Our findings provide valuable normative baselines against which to compare multicultural findings for clinical samples.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)262-273
    Number of pages12
    JournalJournal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology
    Volume42
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Mar 2013

    Fingerprint

    Parents
    Child Behavior
    Checklist
    Self Report
    Population

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Clinical Psychology
    • Developmental and Educational Psychology

    Cite this

    Rescorla, L. A., Ginzburg, S., Achenbach, T. M., Ivanova, M. Y., Almqvist, F., Begovac, I., ... Verhulst, F. C. (2013). Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 42(2), 262-273. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2012.717870

    Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies. / Rescorla, Leslie A.; Ginzburg, Sofia; Achenbach, Thomas M.; Ivanova, Masha Y.; Almqvist, Fredrik; Begovac, Ivan; Bilenberg, Niels; Bird, Hector; Chahed, Myriam; Dobrean, Anca; Döpfner, Manfred; Erol, Nese; Hannesdottir, Helga; Kanbayashi, Yasuko; Lambert, Michael C.; Leung, Patrick W L; Minaei, Asghar; Novik, Torunn S.; Oh, Kyung Ja; Petot, Djaouida; Petot, Jean Michel; Pomalima, Rolando; Rudan, Vlasta; Sawyer, Michael; Simsek, Zeynep; Steinhausen, Hans Christoph; Valverde, José; van der Ende, Jan; Weintraub, Sheila; Metzke, Christa Winkler; Wolanczyk, Tomasz; Zhang, Eugene Yuqing; Zukauskiene, Rita; Verhulst, Frank C.

    In: Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, Vol. 42, No. 2, 03.2013, p. 262-273.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Rescorla, LA, Ginzburg, S, Achenbach, TM, Ivanova, MY, Almqvist, F, Begovac, I, Bilenberg, N, Bird, H, Chahed, M, Dobrean, A, Döpfner, M, Erol, N, Hannesdottir, H, Kanbayashi, Y, Lambert, MC, Leung, PWL, Minaei, A, Novik, TS, Oh, KJ, Petot, D, Petot, JM, Pomalima, R, Rudan, V, Sawyer, M, Simsek, Z, Steinhausen, HC, Valverde, J, van der Ende, J, Weintraub, S, Metzke, CW, Wolanczyk, T, Zhang, EY, Zukauskiene, R & Verhulst, FC 2013, 'Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies', Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, vol. 42, no. 2, pp. 262-273. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2012.717870
    Rescorla, Leslie A. ; Ginzburg, Sofia ; Achenbach, Thomas M. ; Ivanova, Masha Y. ; Almqvist, Fredrik ; Begovac, Ivan ; Bilenberg, Niels ; Bird, Hector ; Chahed, Myriam ; Dobrean, Anca ; Döpfner, Manfred ; Erol, Nese ; Hannesdottir, Helga ; Kanbayashi, Yasuko ; Lambert, Michael C. ; Leung, Patrick W L ; Minaei, Asghar ; Novik, Torunn S. ; Oh, Kyung Ja ; Petot, Djaouida ; Petot, Jean Michel ; Pomalima, Rolando ; Rudan, Vlasta ; Sawyer, Michael ; Simsek, Zeynep ; Steinhausen, Hans Christoph ; Valverde, José ; van der Ende, Jan ; Weintraub, Sheila ; Metzke, Christa Winkler ; Wolanczyk, Tomasz ; Zhang, Eugene Yuqing ; Zukauskiene, Rita ; Verhulst, Frank C. / Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies. In: Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology. 2013 ; Vol. 42, No. 2. pp. 262-273.
    @article{18aecc121a7646678db29b6900d8d1e2,
    title = "Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies",
    abstract = "We used population sample data from 25 societies to answer the following questions: (a) How consistently across societies do adolescents report more problems than their parents report about them? (b) Do levels of parent-adolescent agreement vary among societies for different kinds of problems? (c) How well do parents and adolescents in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-adolescent dyads within each society vary in agreement on item ratings? (e) How well do parent-adolescent dyads within each society agree on the adolescent's deviance status? We used five methods to test cross-informant agreement for ratings obtained from 27,861 adolescents ages 11 to 18 and their parents. Youth Self-Report (YSR) mean scores were significantly higher than Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) mean scores for all problem scales in almost all societies, but the magnitude of the YSR-CBCL discrepancy varied across societies. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied more across societies than across types of problems. Across societies, parents and adolescents tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad parent-adolescent item agreement varied widely in every society. In all societies, both parental noncorroboration of self-reported deviance and adolescent noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Results indicated many multicultural consistencies but also some important differences in parent-adolescent cross-informant agreement. Our findings provide valuable normative baselines against which to compare multicultural findings for clinical samples.",
    author = "Rescorla, {Leslie A.} and Sofia Ginzburg and Achenbach, {Thomas M.} and Ivanova, {Masha Y.} and Fredrik Almqvist and Ivan Begovac and Niels Bilenberg and Hector Bird and Myriam Chahed and Anca Dobrean and Manfred D{\"o}pfner and Nese Erol and Helga Hannesdottir and Yasuko Kanbayashi and Lambert, {Michael C.} and Leung, {Patrick W L} and Asghar Minaei and Novik, {Torunn S.} and Oh, {Kyung Ja} and Djaouida Petot and Petot, {Jean Michel} and Rolando Pomalima and Vlasta Rudan and Michael Sawyer and Zeynep Simsek and Steinhausen, {Hans Christoph} and Jos{\'e} Valverde and {van der Ende}, Jan and Sheila Weintraub and Metzke, {Christa Winkler} and Tomasz Wolanczyk and Zhang, {Eugene Yuqing} and Rita Zukauskiene and Verhulst, {Frank C.}",
    year = "2013",
    month = "3",
    doi = "10.1080/15374416.2012.717870",
    language = "English",
    volume = "42",
    pages = "262--273",
    journal = "Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology",
    issn = "1537-4416",
    publisher = "Routledge",
    number = "2",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Cross-Informant Agreement Between Parent-Reported and Adolescent Self-Reported Problems in 25 Societies

    AU - Rescorla, Leslie A.

    AU - Ginzburg, Sofia

    AU - Achenbach, Thomas M.

    AU - Ivanova, Masha Y.

    AU - Almqvist, Fredrik

    AU - Begovac, Ivan

    AU - Bilenberg, Niels

    AU - Bird, Hector

    AU - Chahed, Myriam

    AU - Dobrean, Anca

    AU - Döpfner, Manfred

    AU - Erol, Nese

    AU - Hannesdottir, Helga

    AU - Kanbayashi, Yasuko

    AU - Lambert, Michael C.

    AU - Leung, Patrick W L

    AU - Minaei, Asghar

    AU - Novik, Torunn S.

    AU - Oh, Kyung Ja

    AU - Petot, Djaouida

    AU - Petot, Jean Michel

    AU - Pomalima, Rolando

    AU - Rudan, Vlasta

    AU - Sawyer, Michael

    AU - Simsek, Zeynep

    AU - Steinhausen, Hans Christoph

    AU - Valverde, José

    AU - van der Ende, Jan

    AU - Weintraub, Sheila

    AU - Metzke, Christa Winkler

    AU - Wolanczyk, Tomasz

    AU - Zhang, Eugene Yuqing

    AU - Zukauskiene, Rita

    AU - Verhulst, Frank C.

    PY - 2013/3

    Y1 - 2013/3

    N2 - We used population sample data from 25 societies to answer the following questions: (a) How consistently across societies do adolescents report more problems than their parents report about them? (b) Do levels of parent-adolescent agreement vary among societies for different kinds of problems? (c) How well do parents and adolescents in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-adolescent dyads within each society vary in agreement on item ratings? (e) How well do parent-adolescent dyads within each society agree on the adolescent's deviance status? We used five methods to test cross-informant agreement for ratings obtained from 27,861 adolescents ages 11 to 18 and their parents. Youth Self-Report (YSR) mean scores were significantly higher than Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) mean scores for all problem scales in almost all societies, but the magnitude of the YSR-CBCL discrepancy varied across societies. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied more across societies than across types of problems. Across societies, parents and adolescents tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad parent-adolescent item agreement varied widely in every society. In all societies, both parental noncorroboration of self-reported deviance and adolescent noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Results indicated many multicultural consistencies but also some important differences in parent-adolescent cross-informant agreement. Our findings provide valuable normative baselines against which to compare multicultural findings for clinical samples.

    AB - We used population sample data from 25 societies to answer the following questions: (a) How consistently across societies do adolescents report more problems than their parents report about them? (b) Do levels of parent-adolescent agreement vary among societies for different kinds of problems? (c) How well do parents and adolescents in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-adolescent dyads within each society vary in agreement on item ratings? (e) How well do parent-adolescent dyads within each society agree on the adolescent's deviance status? We used five methods to test cross-informant agreement for ratings obtained from 27,861 adolescents ages 11 to 18 and their parents. Youth Self-Report (YSR) mean scores were significantly higher than Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) mean scores for all problem scales in almost all societies, but the magnitude of the YSR-CBCL discrepancy varied across societies. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied more across societies than across types of problems. Across societies, parents and adolescents tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad parent-adolescent item agreement varied widely in every society. In all societies, both parental noncorroboration of self-reported deviance and adolescent noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Results indicated many multicultural consistencies but also some important differences in parent-adolescent cross-informant agreement. Our findings provide valuable normative baselines against which to compare multicultural findings for clinical samples.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84876331245&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84876331245&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/15374416.2012.717870

    DO - 10.1080/15374416.2012.717870

    M3 - Article

    C2 - 23009025

    AN - SCOPUS:84876331245

    VL - 42

    SP - 262

    EP - 273

    JO - Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology

    JF - Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology

    SN - 1537-4416

    IS - 2

    ER -