E. Husserlio fenomenologinis projektas ir psichoterapijos problemos

Translated title of the contribution: E. Husserl's phenomenological project and the problems concerning psychotherapy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Though phenomenological philosophy has influenced practitioners of psychotherapy for a long time, it is also true, that it was precisely existentialist approach to phenomenology that was exploited, while the whole initial project of phenomenology initiated by E. Husserl was almost forgotten. In this article I beckon to re-enter this initial understanding of phenomenology, considering methodological problems of psychology and laying down possible perspectives for psychotherapy. First part of the article deals with the methodological problems of psychotherapy while raising the thesis that empirical psychotherapy in principle cannot grasp the ego-structure, misses the true depth of the human experience, which in turn is the real sphere of mental disorders. Hand in hand goes the phenomenological critique of the scientific approach and other phenomenological issues relevant to the reformulation of the goals of psychotherapy. Second part of the article is dedicated to the one of many possible perspectives stemming from the correlation between phenomenology and psychotherapy, i.e. critical comparison of S. Freud's consciousness and unconsciousness and "corresponding" theory of impressional (productive) and reproductive consciousness presented by Husserl. It is indicated that Husserl's approach enables new and constructive reading of Freud's theory of instinctual drive while keeping in mind, that Freud's psychoanalysis cannot be identified with psychotherapy in general. However, the final part of the article suggests some methodological advices for mental care practice from the perspective of phenomenological hermeneutics.

Original languageLithuanian
Pages (from-to)79-140
Number of pages62
JournalProblemos
Volume79
Publication statusPublished - 2011
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Psychotherapy
Edmund Husserl
Phenomenology
Sigmund Freud
Methodological Problems
Consciousness
Psychology
Philosophy
Mental Disorders
Unconsciousness
Existentialist
Hermeneutics
Ego
Reformulation
Human Experience
Psychoanalysis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Philosophy

Cite this

E. Husserlio fenomenologinis projektas ir psichoterapijos problemos. / Briedis, Mindaugas.

In: Problemos, Vol. 79, 2011, p. 79-140.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{8b30b2577135494a95ce6c5bd21c199d,
title = "E. Husserlio fenomenologinis projektas ir psichoterapijos problemos",
abstract = "Though phenomenological philosophy has influenced practitioners of psychotherapy for a long time, it is also true, that it was precisely existentialist approach to phenomenology that was exploited, while the whole initial project of phenomenology initiated by E. Husserl was almost forgotten. In this article I beckon to re-enter this initial understanding of phenomenology, considering methodological problems of psychology and laying down possible perspectives for psychotherapy. First part of the article deals with the methodological problems of psychotherapy while raising the thesis that empirical psychotherapy in principle cannot grasp the ego-structure, misses the true depth of the human experience, which in turn is the real sphere of mental disorders. Hand in hand goes the phenomenological critique of the scientific approach and other phenomenological issues relevant to the reformulation of the goals of psychotherapy. Second part of the article is dedicated to the one of many possible perspectives stemming from the correlation between phenomenology and psychotherapy, i.e. critical comparison of S. Freud's consciousness and unconsciousness and {"}corresponding{"} theory of impressional (productive) and reproductive consciousness presented by Husserl. It is indicated that Husserl's approach enables new and constructive reading of Freud's theory of instinctual drive while keeping in mind, that Freud's psychoanalysis cannot be identified with psychotherapy in general. However, the final part of the article suggests some methodological advices for mental care practice from the perspective of phenomenological hermeneutics.",
keywords = "Instinctive drive, Mental disorders, Phenomenology, Psychological and transcendental ego, Psychotherapy, Reproductive consciousness",
author = "Mindaugas Briedis",
year = "2011",
language = "Lithuanian",
volume = "79",
pages = "79--140",
journal = "Problemos",
issn = "1392-1126",
publisher = "Vilnius university",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - E. Husserlio fenomenologinis projektas ir psichoterapijos problemos

AU - Briedis, Mindaugas

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Though phenomenological philosophy has influenced practitioners of psychotherapy for a long time, it is also true, that it was precisely existentialist approach to phenomenology that was exploited, while the whole initial project of phenomenology initiated by E. Husserl was almost forgotten. In this article I beckon to re-enter this initial understanding of phenomenology, considering methodological problems of psychology and laying down possible perspectives for psychotherapy. First part of the article deals with the methodological problems of psychotherapy while raising the thesis that empirical psychotherapy in principle cannot grasp the ego-structure, misses the true depth of the human experience, which in turn is the real sphere of mental disorders. Hand in hand goes the phenomenological critique of the scientific approach and other phenomenological issues relevant to the reformulation of the goals of psychotherapy. Second part of the article is dedicated to the one of many possible perspectives stemming from the correlation between phenomenology and psychotherapy, i.e. critical comparison of S. Freud's consciousness and unconsciousness and "corresponding" theory of impressional (productive) and reproductive consciousness presented by Husserl. It is indicated that Husserl's approach enables new and constructive reading of Freud's theory of instinctual drive while keeping in mind, that Freud's psychoanalysis cannot be identified with psychotherapy in general. However, the final part of the article suggests some methodological advices for mental care practice from the perspective of phenomenological hermeneutics.

AB - Though phenomenological philosophy has influenced practitioners of psychotherapy for a long time, it is also true, that it was precisely existentialist approach to phenomenology that was exploited, while the whole initial project of phenomenology initiated by E. Husserl was almost forgotten. In this article I beckon to re-enter this initial understanding of phenomenology, considering methodological problems of psychology and laying down possible perspectives for psychotherapy. First part of the article deals with the methodological problems of psychotherapy while raising the thesis that empirical psychotherapy in principle cannot grasp the ego-structure, misses the true depth of the human experience, which in turn is the real sphere of mental disorders. Hand in hand goes the phenomenological critique of the scientific approach and other phenomenological issues relevant to the reformulation of the goals of psychotherapy. Second part of the article is dedicated to the one of many possible perspectives stemming from the correlation between phenomenology and psychotherapy, i.e. critical comparison of S. Freud's consciousness and unconsciousness and "corresponding" theory of impressional (productive) and reproductive consciousness presented by Husserl. It is indicated that Husserl's approach enables new and constructive reading of Freud's theory of instinctual drive while keeping in mind, that Freud's psychoanalysis cannot be identified with psychotherapy in general. However, the final part of the article suggests some methodological advices for mental care practice from the perspective of phenomenological hermeneutics.

KW - Instinctive drive

KW - Mental disorders

KW - Phenomenology

KW - Psychological and transcendental ego

KW - Psychotherapy

KW - Reproductive consciousness

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79953731594&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79953731594&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:79953731594

VL - 79

SP - 79

EP - 140

JO - Problemos

JF - Problemos

SN - 1392-1126

ER -