Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies

Leslie A. Rescorla, Lauren Bochicchio, Thomas M. Achenbach, Masha Y. Ivanova, Fredrik Almqvist, Ivan Begovac, Niels Bilenberg, Hector Bird, Anca Dobrean, Nese Erol, Eric Fombonne, Antonio Fonseca, Alessandra Frigerio, Daniel S S Fung, Michael C. Lambert, Patrick W L Leung, Xianchen Liu, Ivica Marković, Jasminka Markovic, Asghar Minaei & 12 others Yoon Phaik Ooi, Alexandra Roussos, Vlasta Rudan, Zeynep Simsek, Jan van der Ende, Sheila Weintraub, Tomasz Wolanczyk, Bernardine Woo, Bahr Weiss, John Weisz, Rita Zukauskiene, Frank C. Verhulst

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    49 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Parent-teacher cross-informant agreement, although usually modest, may provide important clinical information. Using data for 27,962 children from 21 societies, we asked the following: (a) Do parents report more problems than teachers, and does this vary by society, age, gender, or type of problem? (b) Does parent-teacher agreement vary across different problem scales or across societies? (c) How well do parents and teachers in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-teacher dyads in different societies vary in within-dyad agreement on problem items? (e) How well do parents and teachers in 21 societies agree on whether the child's problem level exceeds a deviance threshold? We used five methods to test agreement for Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) and Teacher's Report Form (TRF) ratings. CBCL scores were higher than TRF scores on most scales, but the informant differences varied in magnitude across the societies studied. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied moderately across societies studied and were significantly higher for Externalizing than Internalizing problems. Parents and teachers tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad item agreement varied widely in every society studied. In all societies studied, both parental noncorroboration of teacher-reported deviance and teacher noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Our findings underscore the importance of obtaining information from parents and teachers when evaluating and treating children, highlight the need to use multiple methods of quantifying cross-informant agreement, and provide comprehensive baselines for patterns of parent-teacher agreement across 21 societies.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)627-642
    Number of pages16
    JournalJournal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology
    Volume43
    Issue number4
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2014

    Fingerprint

    Parents
    Child Behavior
    Checklist

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Clinical Psychology
    • Developmental and Educational Psychology

    Cite this

    Rescorla, L. A., Bochicchio, L., Achenbach, T. M., Ivanova, M. Y., Almqvist, F., Begovac, I., ... Verhulst, F. C. (2014). Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 43(4), 627-642. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2014.900719

    Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies. / Rescorla, Leslie A.; Bochicchio, Lauren; Achenbach, Thomas M.; Ivanova, Masha Y.; Almqvist, Fredrik; Begovac, Ivan; Bilenberg, Niels; Bird, Hector; Dobrean, Anca; Erol, Nese; Fombonne, Eric; Fonseca, Antonio; Frigerio, Alessandra; Fung, Daniel S S; Lambert, Michael C.; Leung, Patrick W L; Liu, Xianchen; Marković, Ivica; Markovic, Jasminka; Minaei, Asghar; Ooi, Yoon Phaik; Roussos, Alexandra; Rudan, Vlasta; Simsek, Zeynep; van der Ende, Jan; Weintraub, Sheila; Wolanczyk, Tomasz; Woo, Bernardine; Weiss, Bahr; Weisz, John; Zukauskiene, Rita; Verhulst, Frank C.

    In: Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, Vol. 43, No. 4, 2014, p. 627-642.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Rescorla, LA, Bochicchio, L, Achenbach, TM, Ivanova, MY, Almqvist, F, Begovac, I, Bilenberg, N, Bird, H, Dobrean, A, Erol, N, Fombonne, E, Fonseca, A, Frigerio, A, Fung, DSS, Lambert, MC, Leung, PWL, Liu, X, Marković, I, Markovic, J, Minaei, A, Ooi, YP, Roussos, A, Rudan, V, Simsek, Z, van der Ende, J, Weintraub, S, Wolanczyk, T, Woo, B, Weiss, B, Weisz, J, Zukauskiene, R & Verhulst, FC 2014, 'Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies', Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, vol. 43, no. 4, pp. 627-642. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2014.900719
    Rescorla LA, Bochicchio L, Achenbach TM, Ivanova MY, Almqvist F, Begovac I et al. Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology. 2014;43(4):627-642. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2014.900719
    Rescorla, Leslie A. ; Bochicchio, Lauren ; Achenbach, Thomas M. ; Ivanova, Masha Y. ; Almqvist, Fredrik ; Begovac, Ivan ; Bilenberg, Niels ; Bird, Hector ; Dobrean, Anca ; Erol, Nese ; Fombonne, Eric ; Fonseca, Antonio ; Frigerio, Alessandra ; Fung, Daniel S S ; Lambert, Michael C. ; Leung, Patrick W L ; Liu, Xianchen ; Marković, Ivica ; Markovic, Jasminka ; Minaei, Asghar ; Ooi, Yoon Phaik ; Roussos, Alexandra ; Rudan, Vlasta ; Simsek, Zeynep ; van der Ende, Jan ; Weintraub, Sheila ; Wolanczyk, Tomasz ; Woo, Bernardine ; Weiss, Bahr ; Weisz, John ; Zukauskiene, Rita ; Verhulst, Frank C. / Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies. In: Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology. 2014 ; Vol. 43, No. 4. pp. 627-642.
    @article{ce32641cff43480c8d842aa4d87be014,
    title = "Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies",
    abstract = "Parent-teacher cross-informant agreement, although usually modest, may provide important clinical information. Using data for 27,962 children from 21 societies, we asked the following: (a) Do parents report more problems than teachers, and does this vary by society, age, gender, or type of problem? (b) Does parent-teacher agreement vary across different problem scales or across societies? (c) How well do parents and teachers in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-teacher dyads in different societies vary in within-dyad agreement on problem items? (e) How well do parents and teachers in 21 societies agree on whether the child's problem level exceeds a deviance threshold? We used five methods to test agreement for Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) and Teacher's Report Form (TRF) ratings. CBCL scores were higher than TRF scores on most scales, but the informant differences varied in magnitude across the societies studied. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied moderately across societies studied and were significantly higher for Externalizing than Internalizing problems. Parents and teachers tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad item agreement varied widely in every society studied. In all societies studied, both parental noncorroboration of teacher-reported deviance and teacher noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Our findings underscore the importance of obtaining information from parents and teachers when evaluating and treating children, highlight the need to use multiple methods of quantifying cross-informant agreement, and provide comprehensive baselines for patterns of parent-teacher agreement across 21 societies.",
    author = "Rescorla, {Leslie A.} and Lauren Bochicchio and Achenbach, {Thomas M.} and Ivanova, {Masha Y.} and Fredrik Almqvist and Ivan Begovac and Niels Bilenberg and Hector Bird and Anca Dobrean and Nese Erol and Eric Fombonne and Antonio Fonseca and Alessandra Frigerio and Fung, {Daniel S S} and Lambert, {Michael C.} and Leung, {Patrick W L} and Xianchen Liu and Ivica Marković and Jasminka Markovic and Asghar Minaei and Ooi, {Yoon Phaik} and Alexandra Roussos and Vlasta Rudan and Zeynep Simsek and {van der Ende}, Jan and Sheila Weintraub and Tomasz Wolanczyk and Bernardine Woo and Bahr Weiss and John Weisz and Rita Zukauskiene and Verhulst, {Frank C.}",
    year = "2014",
    doi = "10.1080/15374416.2014.900719",
    language = "English",
    volume = "43",
    pages = "627--642",
    journal = "Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology",
    issn = "1537-4416",
    publisher = "Routledge",
    number = "4",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Parent-Teacher Agreement on Children's Problems in 21 Societies

    AU - Rescorla, Leslie A.

    AU - Bochicchio, Lauren

    AU - Achenbach, Thomas M.

    AU - Ivanova, Masha Y.

    AU - Almqvist, Fredrik

    AU - Begovac, Ivan

    AU - Bilenberg, Niels

    AU - Bird, Hector

    AU - Dobrean, Anca

    AU - Erol, Nese

    AU - Fombonne, Eric

    AU - Fonseca, Antonio

    AU - Frigerio, Alessandra

    AU - Fung, Daniel S S

    AU - Lambert, Michael C.

    AU - Leung, Patrick W L

    AU - Liu, Xianchen

    AU - Marković, Ivica

    AU - Markovic, Jasminka

    AU - Minaei, Asghar

    AU - Ooi, Yoon Phaik

    AU - Roussos, Alexandra

    AU - Rudan, Vlasta

    AU - Simsek, Zeynep

    AU - van der Ende, Jan

    AU - Weintraub, Sheila

    AU - Wolanczyk, Tomasz

    AU - Woo, Bernardine

    AU - Weiss, Bahr

    AU - Weisz, John

    AU - Zukauskiene, Rita

    AU - Verhulst, Frank C.

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - Parent-teacher cross-informant agreement, although usually modest, may provide important clinical information. Using data for 27,962 children from 21 societies, we asked the following: (a) Do parents report more problems than teachers, and does this vary by society, age, gender, or type of problem? (b) Does parent-teacher agreement vary across different problem scales or across societies? (c) How well do parents and teachers in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-teacher dyads in different societies vary in within-dyad agreement on problem items? (e) How well do parents and teachers in 21 societies agree on whether the child's problem level exceeds a deviance threshold? We used five methods to test agreement for Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) and Teacher's Report Form (TRF) ratings. CBCL scores were higher than TRF scores on most scales, but the informant differences varied in magnitude across the societies studied. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied moderately across societies studied and were significantly higher for Externalizing than Internalizing problems. Parents and teachers tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad item agreement varied widely in every society studied. In all societies studied, both parental noncorroboration of teacher-reported deviance and teacher noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Our findings underscore the importance of obtaining information from parents and teachers when evaluating and treating children, highlight the need to use multiple methods of quantifying cross-informant agreement, and provide comprehensive baselines for patterns of parent-teacher agreement across 21 societies.

    AB - Parent-teacher cross-informant agreement, although usually modest, may provide important clinical information. Using data for 27,962 children from 21 societies, we asked the following: (a) Do parents report more problems than teachers, and does this vary by society, age, gender, or type of problem? (b) Does parent-teacher agreement vary across different problem scales or across societies? (c) How well do parents and teachers in different societies agree on problem item ratings? (d) How much do parent-teacher dyads in different societies vary in within-dyad agreement on problem items? (e) How well do parents and teachers in 21 societies agree on whether the child's problem level exceeds a deviance threshold? We used five methods to test agreement for Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) and Teacher's Report Form (TRF) ratings. CBCL scores were higher than TRF scores on most scales, but the informant differences varied in magnitude across the societies studied. Cross-informant correlations for problem scale scores varied moderately across societies studied and were significantly higher for Externalizing than Internalizing problems. Parents and teachers tended to rate the same items as low, medium, or high, but within-dyad item agreement varied widely in every society studied. In all societies studied, both parental noncorroboration of teacher-reported deviance and teacher noncorroboration of parent-reported deviance were common. Our findings underscore the importance of obtaining information from parents and teachers when evaluating and treating children, highlight the need to use multiple methods of quantifying cross-informant agreement, and provide comprehensive baselines for patterns of parent-teacher agreement across 21 societies.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84904389186&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84904389186&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/15374416.2014.900719

    DO - 10.1080/15374416.2014.900719

    M3 - Article

    VL - 43

    SP - 627

    EP - 642

    JO - Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology

    JF - Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology

    SN - 1537-4416

    IS - 4

    ER -