R&D policy impact on research excellence

Kristina Babelyte, Birutė Mikulskienė

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Pacing the worldwide economic recession, the public research and development (R&D) policy undergo the increasing pressure to economize and improve research performance levels in this way complying with public accountability. Thus the design of R&D policy has to integrate an appropriate set of research performance criteria together with the balanced choice of relevant indicators for the allocation of scarce funds for the very purpose of pursuing scientific advancement in the frames of international rivalry. During several last decades the discourse of the EU politicians expanded with the term of "research excellence", which became conceptual background for further EU R&D policy development. Often excellence in research is used as synonym of "research quality". Nevertheless, rivalry for the highest evaluation of research performance has not yet provided with a single and fixed definition of "research excellence". This paper aims to outline the content of excellence in research and, investigating the existing Lithuanian experience to measure it, discuss the R&D policy intervention impacts on the process and the results of pursuing high level research. The methods of research used are grounded on the investigation of Lithuanian legal acts, valid in the field of R&D and conditioning the performance of public R&D institutions. Two levels of policy intervention: institution and individual are taken into consideration. Also, in the light of research excellence measurement R&D output assessment methodology used by the Government as a basic institutional funding instrument is analyzed. The conclusions mark that due to the conditions of ambiguous definition of "research excellence" the need for the methods to recognize and identify excellence in research are vital. However, its pro-active state-level management practices should contain an umbrella of flexible, well-balanced and situation receptive procedures. Therewith, the research excellence encouragement instruments within the framework of the state’s R&D policy should cover the individual and institutional level endorsed and promoted by sustainable and diversified measures.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)7-9
JournalEuropean integration studies
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Fingerprint

Policy impact
Excellence
Research performance
Policy intervention
Rivalry
Funding
Recession
Conditioning
R&D policy
Accountability
Policy development
Research quality
Performance criteria
Public research
Evaluation
Government
Methodology
Politicians
Performance levels
Discourse

Keywords

  • R&D policy
  • Research excellence

Cite this

R&D policy impact on research excellence. / Babelyte, Kristina; Mikulskienė, Birutė .

In: European integration studies, No. 3, 2009, p. 7-9.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9c165ad82ef54fa2b384c618f8e137ed,
title = "R&D policy impact on research excellence",
abstract = "Pacing the worldwide economic recession, the public research and development (R&D) policy undergo the increasing pressure to economize and improve research performance levels in this way complying with public accountability. Thus the design of R&D policy has to integrate an appropriate set of research performance criteria together with the balanced choice of relevant indicators for the allocation of scarce funds for the very purpose of pursuing scientific advancement in the frames of international rivalry. During several last decades the discourse of the EU politicians expanded with the term of {"}research excellence{"}, which became conceptual background for further EU R&D policy development. Often excellence in research is used as synonym of {"}research quality{"}. Nevertheless, rivalry for the highest evaluation of research performance has not yet provided with a single and fixed definition of {"}research excellence{"}. This paper aims to outline the content of excellence in research and, investigating the existing Lithuanian experience to measure it, discuss the R&D policy intervention impacts on the process and the results of pursuing high level research. The methods of research used are grounded on the investigation of Lithuanian legal acts, valid in the field of R&D and conditioning the performance of public R&D institutions. Two levels of policy intervention: institution and individual are taken into consideration. Also, in the light of research excellence measurement R&D output assessment methodology used by the Government as a basic institutional funding instrument is analyzed. The conclusions mark that due to the conditions of ambiguous definition of {"}research excellence{"} the need for the methods to recognize and identify excellence in research are vital. However, its pro-active state-level management practices should contain an umbrella of flexible, well-balanced and situation receptive procedures. Therewith, the research excellence encouragement instruments within the framework of the state’s R&D policy should cover the individual and institutional level endorsed and promoted by sustainable and diversified measures.",
keywords = "R&D policy, Research excellence",
author = "Kristina Babelyte and Birutė Mikulskienė",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
pages = "7--9",
journal = "European integration studies",
issn = "1822-8402",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - R&D policy impact on research excellence

AU - Babelyte, Kristina

AU - Mikulskienė, Birutė

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - Pacing the worldwide economic recession, the public research and development (R&D) policy undergo the increasing pressure to economize and improve research performance levels in this way complying with public accountability. Thus the design of R&D policy has to integrate an appropriate set of research performance criteria together with the balanced choice of relevant indicators for the allocation of scarce funds for the very purpose of pursuing scientific advancement in the frames of international rivalry. During several last decades the discourse of the EU politicians expanded with the term of "research excellence", which became conceptual background for further EU R&D policy development. Often excellence in research is used as synonym of "research quality". Nevertheless, rivalry for the highest evaluation of research performance has not yet provided with a single and fixed definition of "research excellence". This paper aims to outline the content of excellence in research and, investigating the existing Lithuanian experience to measure it, discuss the R&D policy intervention impacts on the process and the results of pursuing high level research. The methods of research used are grounded on the investigation of Lithuanian legal acts, valid in the field of R&D and conditioning the performance of public R&D institutions. Two levels of policy intervention: institution and individual are taken into consideration. Also, in the light of research excellence measurement R&D output assessment methodology used by the Government as a basic institutional funding instrument is analyzed. The conclusions mark that due to the conditions of ambiguous definition of "research excellence" the need for the methods to recognize and identify excellence in research are vital. However, its pro-active state-level management practices should contain an umbrella of flexible, well-balanced and situation receptive procedures. Therewith, the research excellence encouragement instruments within the framework of the state’s R&D policy should cover the individual and institutional level endorsed and promoted by sustainable and diversified measures.

AB - Pacing the worldwide economic recession, the public research and development (R&D) policy undergo the increasing pressure to economize and improve research performance levels in this way complying with public accountability. Thus the design of R&D policy has to integrate an appropriate set of research performance criteria together with the balanced choice of relevant indicators for the allocation of scarce funds for the very purpose of pursuing scientific advancement in the frames of international rivalry. During several last decades the discourse of the EU politicians expanded with the term of "research excellence", which became conceptual background for further EU R&D policy development. Often excellence in research is used as synonym of "research quality". Nevertheless, rivalry for the highest evaluation of research performance has not yet provided with a single and fixed definition of "research excellence". This paper aims to outline the content of excellence in research and, investigating the existing Lithuanian experience to measure it, discuss the R&D policy intervention impacts on the process and the results of pursuing high level research. The methods of research used are grounded on the investigation of Lithuanian legal acts, valid in the field of R&D and conditioning the performance of public R&D institutions. Two levels of policy intervention: institution and individual are taken into consideration. Also, in the light of research excellence measurement R&D output assessment methodology used by the Government as a basic institutional funding instrument is analyzed. The conclusions mark that due to the conditions of ambiguous definition of "research excellence" the need for the methods to recognize and identify excellence in research are vital. However, its pro-active state-level management practices should contain an umbrella of flexible, well-balanced and situation receptive procedures. Therewith, the research excellence encouragement instruments within the framework of the state’s R&D policy should cover the individual and institutional level endorsed and promoted by sustainable and diversified measures.

KW - R&D policy

KW - Research excellence

M3 - Article

SP - 7

EP - 9

JO - European integration studies

JF - European integration studies

SN - 1822-8402

IS - 3

ER -